This is a question that I’ve been asked countless times over the course of my career. The answer isn’t always as clear as we may think and in recent years, it’s gotten more and more difficult to make the choice.
The situation is usually similar. Either an unexpected breakdown or system failure brings the vehicle into the shop. Maybe it died on the road and needed to be towed in or maybe there’s a horrible noise happening that just started. Maybe it is a warning light that has been on for a while but now the vehicle is running poorly. Or it could just be a backlog of maintenance that hasn’t been completed and is overdue all at once.
In any case, the vehicle owner is now facing a larger than expected bill and they are not sure if the vehicle is worth it. “That’s more than it’s worth” is a common phrase, but is it really? For many, many years, the automotive industry has used the “Blue Book” as a reference of value for cars and trucks. In reality, a vehicle is worth what someone is willing to pay for it. The “Blue Book” used to be an actual book, but now, it – like most resources these days – has moved online. You can put in some details about your vehicle, answer a few questions and the program will give you a valuation.
The problem these days – and especially since COVID – is that the cost to replace that vehicle is higher than ever. With the drop in sales and the resulting supply chain disruptions of COVID and the fact that the U.S. is still not back to pre-COVID sales numbers of new vehicles, both the cost of new and used vehicles are both higher than they’ve ever been.
So, let’s say for example that that unexpected repair is going to cost $5000, and you estimate the value of your car at $4500. Simple, right? That repair is more than the car is worth, so why bother fixing it? Let’s look at a few factors…
- How long have you owned that car and do you sill like it enough to keep it for 5 years? This is always my first question. If you don’t really like the vehicle in the first place, you probably won’t be crazy about the idea of keeping it a few more years. This is an important decision to make, because if you make the repairs, you will want to get the most value out of it – and that means keeping it long enough.
- Has it been well maintained and are you aware of any issues that may need attention soon? If you have owned it for several years, you know the maintenance history. You know how it’s been cared for and should know if there are any known issues that may have been planned for. We can never know for sure how long a vehicle will last, but a good service history at a good shop will be the best tool you have. Does it need tires soon? When were the brakes done last? Are all of the fluids up to date? We want to know the total investment needed to make the vehicle safe and reliable before we can give any advice.
- How much will it cost to replace your vehicle? The average price of a new vehicle is over $40,000 and the average price of a good, newer, used vehicle is over $25,000. Consider that interest rates on loans are higher than they have been for many years and used car loans are more expensive (higher interest rate) than manufacturer-subsidized new car loans and the monthly cost is easily several hundred dollars or more.
- What if I just buy an older used car for about what mine is worth? The problem with this plan – let’s call it a lateral move – is that you don’t really know the history. Yes, there is Car Fax that can give you information and if you buy from a private party that has kept good records, that is a good sign. But it can be risky to expect a high-mileage vehicle to give you as many miles as your existing vehicle with the needed repairs.
Now, new or used, any car or truck will need tires, brakes, regular maintenance and occasional repair.
So, choices are buying a new or a newer used vehicle and taking on higher monthly payments of several hundred dollars or more…buying an older, higher-mileage vehicle with limited history available…or, making the investment into your own vehicle which spread out over 3 to 5 years boils down to between $90-$140 per month and it becomes clearer that even if your car or truck “isn’t worth it” …maybe it is, after all!
Thanks for reading and be sure to contact us with any questions you may have!
Todd Ainsworth, owner – Swedish Automotive